It is possible, then, to have an entire library of materials in your shop with very little set-up needed to begin a cut. t is well made and feels like it will hold up. Most of the things I could think of a use for are multiples or intricate things where I wouldn't want to be hunched over a table for an hour. There are hundreds of user-uploaded project ideas on their website, and a busy forum to keep in touch with other users. Hi Bill, it seems that youre being pulled to the dark side of the ww force. Being passionate about whatever is what makes doing stuff worthwhile for me at least. You can find these for a variety of design programs. It could have been lighter on low-end models, Few small-sized machines on the low-end CNC machines. No need for layout tools. 1/4 . Since it has the patterns pre-stored it wouldnt need the scanning step, the calibration is just to account for offset on any given sheet. If you want to review the thing, thats fine, but this isnt a review. Festool makes no representations about the accuracy, reliability, completeness or timeliness of the material on this website or about the results to be obtained from using the website. I have always believed in the right tool for the job. lire Min. More User Friendly [Best Overall]:X-Carve is better for those who need a little extra support, either from Inventables or from other X-Carve users. It comes with a tutorial to walk you through the basic features, and straight away you can see a preview of what youve made: The Pro version costs $19.99 per month, and gives you access to V-Carving (carving with a v-shaped bit), a customizable font library (sometimes referred to as Vectric Vcarve Desktop), and raster toolpaths. itd be great for offsite work or places you cant take the cnc, or when its too big a material. Its nowhere near an entire workshop. So first off, this post is much closer to an advertisement than I like to see on HaD. I would question the rigidity of the setup, but it seems to work well if you don't need sub-millimeter precision. https://preorder.shapertools.com/ref/U8MX9QGUU, Ive debated the cost for a long time. No, but Shaper Origin works with Festool products, enhancing your existing workflows and bringing new capabilities to your workshop. When I was done working, that tape came right off as well, again, with no glue, and it had been sitting outside in the driveway getting sun through all that time. https://preorder.shapertools.com/ref/A8JX6BMBW. It will make for some interesting reviews as to see if the pros outweigh the cons. Mikiquo has added a new log for SyncCarb. Stephen Chasey liked "Desk Accessory" CNC Milling Machine. Thought that was interesting, and the thoughts about having to actually rout everything yourself is a fair point. I was hoping to get some thoughts on best materials for beginning woodworking projects and user friendly design . I do a lot of design in sketchup for trade show booths and convert different components (complex curves for wall panels mainly) to vector files to cut ribs on on our 44 cnc. But since it is HaD AND the invention costs $2K (really ???) It's intuitive, doesn't require dedicated space, and can provide lots of shortcuts to complete projects quicker and with less stress. For what its worth, the X carve is open source. Does it load slow because you have bad connection? The Sideboard, a small MDF board, secures the X-Controller to the X-Carve and helps to organise the wires properly (another major complaint that people had about the previous model). The X-Carve has a working area of 800x800mm. Our most compact CNC is affordable, versatile, and small enough to take anywhere. However, it is quite expensive, around $3K. Check out MatterHackers for the latest promos here, Why Go with the X-Carve? I went ahead and pre-ordered minefor those on the fence and maybe $100 off will tip you over, heres a link where we can both save. Theres simply too much work. The content contained on this site is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. And i think id rather pay more, but have my money until i can buy it to have it actually shipped quickly to me. I can imagine that someone somewhere is already hooking up webcam to the laptop and tries to prove that this can be done for 10% of the cost. Its not new, but its the difference between crude and gasoline. If not I recommend you to leave it to a professional tapeer. Slow yes. This article literally claims this device is as transformative to woodworking as the saw blade. Its almost identical to the Makita 1-1/4inch router, which Carbide previously used with their Shapeoko machines before replacing it with their own version. It was assumed that the user would take care of the Z depth. I actually dont know. Could I make, say, relief maps with it as I could with a gantry router? The tape seems like how machine vision was handled in 1980s, mark up the thing you want to see with reference points. This includes your ability to use the tool. Both work in a similar way, and theyre both designed to be used at home by smaller businesses or by hobbyists. Its very easy to tell which way youre moving and at what speed with far less sensing than it takes to know where youre actually located in space. CNC machines can handle 3D relief carving and true V-carving. Onefinity vs. Shapeoko CNC {2021}: Which one should you buy? If i could buy it now, id do it right away (even if i would probably build my CNC, because! More than outlines are possible. It may take a few attempts at alignment to get the accuracy just right. They came up with a wayto place an arbitrary load on the spindle. Due to a greater viewing angle, you'll also have more legibility when viewing Origin on the go at the workbench. Festool and its affiliates cannot be responsible for improper postings or your reliance on the website's material. The Shapeoko 3 CNC Router Kit comes with a wall adapter that can be used to operate the machine at 110-220 V. Conclusion: Shapeoko 3 Review From hardware elements to Carbide Create and Carbide Motion software, almost everything about Shapeoko 3 has been put together keeping the users in mind. Thats the genius. There'd be no place for it. And no, you do not give a $20/hour worker responsibility over a multi million dollar machine. Dont be cheap an buy the $0.75 ones tho, quality is terrible and they leave residue that is a pain to remove. I haven't measured the accuracy but so far have found the following: Thanks to those who have given their experiences with the shaper it's really helpful to hear your thoughts. The Augmented reality work is really cool and Im sure it took a lot of smarts to get operational, but this seems to be a solution in search of a problem. active 911 calls fort worth - scimathdll.com The waste board is designed specifically for the X-Carve and has pre-drilled and counterbored holes to attach the clamps. No need for holding it is a big plus. Our house is of a very modern style and the furniture I will be building needs to reflect that. I was really excited about this at first, but the more I think about the likely limitations the less I believe that it has value anywhere ???????????????? Or, other way round, its exploiting us plentiful clumsy meatbags to carry it around, and take the work off precious robot motors. What about metric units? As for size & cost, I bought a little gantry machine for $2,200 some years back that has a working area of only 13x24, figuring that it would get me started and Id soon replace it with a larger model. jack cichy pff This gives it a bit of an advantage over the X-Carve, which can be a lengthy process. Daniel Valuch Chats About CERNs High Caliber Hacking, Hackaday Podcast 208: Hallucinating Robots, Floppy Cartridges, And A Flexure Synth French Horn, This Week In Security: OpenEMR, Bing Chat, And Alien Kills Pixels, Missing Finger Gets A Simple Yet Fancy Replacement. catwastesoil.co.uk It can be produced by Adobe illustrator, sketchup, or many other applications. Check the coverage of the tool from the bigger sites. This reminds me of the Silouette I bought my wife, it takes our shirts (and others) from puffy paint cringe-monsters to professional looking items. $2K is *not* expensive for this tool. A CNC does almost everything the Origin can as long as it fits within the confines of the bed, but a Shaper Origin cannot do everything that a CNC can do. I just tested this turn off acceleration or enhance pointer precision in the mouse settings and line your cursor up with a reference point on screen. Here the main problems, the camera resolution, the dirtiness of the camera lenses, tape on not straight surface etc. I appreciate you genuinely loved it, and the company are one of us. All in all, for what it can do, i dont think 2K is such a ludicrous price. There is really nothing that is secret about the fiducials so third-party tape should be pretty easy to come by if there is demand. There is sometimes insufficient quality or quantity of tape in your workspace. One thing for sure, it needs dust collection as its first improvement. Yeah I think thats crossing a line, you should probably cut that shit out. The device starts to evolve. The tool has an automatic cut correction. If something like Shaper Origin supported being able to do . It was quite a challenge to find a manufacturer who could produce the fiducial tape. But even if you dont want to call that a saw, in the woodworking discussion sense, it still is the invention-foundation. Shaper Origin combines computer-guided accuracy with hand-held familiarity. I do all my cad work in metric when cutting things with Origin. Ill bet the Origins accuracy will never be good enough for milling PCBs. To reduce the risk of serious injury and/or damage to your Festool product, always read, understand and follow all warnings and instructions in your Festool product's Instruction Manual. Reviewers praise the DeWalt router compared to the kind used in previous versions of the X-Carve. The Shaper Origin has no theoretical limits on work area. ?????????????????! The core of this technology is bringing power back to us meatbags, from the pincers of our robotic overlords. Yes, if you know how to use tape. Available for PreSale now! I think its safe to assume that the Shaper Origin can produce parts of equal quality as the X-Carve in the same sorts of materials. Dont forget: we have already the 21st century. I also think of it as a revolutionary tool, as a CNC that could be used in a small apartment, and replace many other tools, as well as open new uses (engraving cool patterns on wood beams in your home!). I can see an open source router-add on version of this tool come out for a hundred bucks in a couple years. In terms of design, it looks pretty simple, with black aluminum rails and a simple cutting area. We just got the Origin for my school's FabLab and are pumped to start using it. But its 2K AND I have to move it around by hand? Can we get along? It makes us more. Optionally, just type in the dimension of the circle using the onscreen keyboard. The $1,490 Early Bird Specials are all gone, and it appears there are only 23 units left, period, selling for $1,750. if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'thewhittlingguide_com-large-mobile-banner-2','ezslot_6',107,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-thewhittlingguide_com-large-mobile-banner-2-0');The user also designs or downloads designs from online project libraries, then uploads the drawing to Goliath. Festool makes no representations about the accuracy, reliability, completeness or timeliness of the material on this website or about the results to be obtained from using the website. Its like a magic pencil that summons whatever it draws. shaper origin vs shapeoko I would not mind moving it by hand and if manually moving it is really the biggest problem, I think that they will come up with a version that has caterpillar tracks and rides across your work piece. is fair game. The correction is cool, but again, tracing patterns is easily accomplished by hand for most people. The shaper origin also has 3 axis motion, but the x-y motion is small and only there to compensate for the human in the loop control. Suddenly complex cutson any flat surface areeasy. RW Id like to point out that the early indexed mouse pads were absolute position, more similar to todays graphics tablets than an optical mouse. If you want to talk about all the other stuff, start a new thread. However, what i see is a cleverly designed tool, proper scientific testing of elements, a lot of work in incremental improving the prototypes, etc. You wont lose your progress on the workpiece. It should be > 100% by your logic. The next version featured the eccentric mechanism. Ive used a number of hobby-grade and commercial grade CNC machines over the years, and the thought of leaving one unattended for long periods of time is just silly. Its tempting to boil it down and say that its a CNC machine, or a router. Its unreasonable to ask Shaper to design around this scenario a scenario that seems unlikely to happen given that theres simply no advantage to placing the optical tape on your stock any earlier than when youre actually going to be making cuts. It is unfortunately too much for me. While the two generations look similar in appearance, there are a few notable exceptions. Instead of considering that people only want that to show off, try be less condescending and consider other point of view Shaper Origin Handheld CNC Router - CNC Level Precision Cutting - Portable - SO1-NN - Inlays, Custom Joinery, Engraving, Lettering, Fine Woodworking, Depth Control + Router Bits, Tape and Systainer - - Amazon.com Consider these available items Shaper Workstation - Ultimate workholding and fixturing solution - SW1-AA - Easily adjustable shelf f 25 The Shaper Origin looks and feels like a conventional router but acts like a CNC. It will be my first foray into CNC. After a long wait, Shaper has opened up pre-orders for the device. If you decide that Origin is not for you, return the tool. Door latch doesnt line up with the strike plate, Dewalt DW745 vs Makita MLT100 | Compact Table Saw Comparison. I don't know if people have seen the Shaper Origin which is cross between a router and a CNC, I am always impressed with how it works. Nearly four years ago, Shaper joined the TTS Group to stand alongside other top industry brands including Festool, Sawstop, and Tanos. The standard Shapeoko 3 is only $1,320. Sometimes reviews are positive. I really just want to have CNC capability in my workshop, mainly for accurate jig making, or templates, or whatever else it comes in handy for. Heh, anyone who already has a hernia or back injury for sure. The Shapeoko machines do in fact have accessories available. ), as it would cover the vast majority of my needs. This platform used regular lead screws and linear bearings to perform the translations. Simple & Cheaper CNC Shaper | Hackaday.io So here are the points: The Basket can track whos using the tool, who broke the tool, its current status, and much more. Given the very high price of this tool combined with the possibility of an alternative solution, it seems to me that it makes the most sense to wait and see how things turn out before committing to it. They are made of carbide, a material known for maintaining a sharp cutting edge for a long time. We can't thank the community of woodworkers and craftspeople around the world enough for putting Origin through its paces over the years. Firstly, its not cloud-based. Shaper could be under a lot of financial stress and unable to meet the demand for many refunds. How Much Does a 3D Printer Cost? What does it have to offer, particularly vs laser cutting and laser engraving maching (laser tech in general)? shaper claims your average person can do 0.01 with the origin. I will be making a 12m floor to ceiling bookcase with a stepped from and drawers at the bottom if this works as advertised, I could imagine making up the pieces with to finish quality with all joints built in. . there are hundreds of router spindles out there, and Shaper wanted to find one that would provide the best power, control, quality, and cost to integrate into Origin, an dynamically adjust the load by inducing eddy currents in the metal. The way it is described, I cant see it doing more than 75% of what a normal hand router could do with an experienced operator. Im looking forward to the drama in 5 years when half the company splits off to make the Original Origin vs Genuine Origin. We have spent years in our homes creating projects, and learning new software and are here to share our learnings here. Here he is using the actual workpiece as his bed. It also has to be durable. Although Festool strives for accuracy in the website material, the website may contain inaccuracies. Fortunately Shaper has recently begun posting more videos of the device in action. The Shapeoko Pro was launched in September 2020. you also can not do 3d contouring. The augmented portion is a suite of sensors and an onboard computer. If the Shaper Origin were available right now the problem of needing more work area would be easy to solve. A mouse is a lot closer to its mat than this is. And medicine manufacturer CEOs didnt grow up dreaming of making epi pens $600, but they sure did..And it isnt an accident. The CNC router kit a DeWalt 611 is very powerful, and it works well in this setup. Great tool, if your day to day work regularly requires you to cut complex and precise holes on site and in place rather than allowing you to use a CNC in your shop then assemble on site. Originderives most of its tracking power from a carefully mounted camera on the forward facing side of the device. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2130625347/goliath-cnc-an-autonomous-robotic-machine-tool-for, Quote from: Rollin22Petes on October 06, 2017, 08:26 PM, Quote from: Timtool on October 07, 2017, 11:09 AM, Quote from: Richard/RMW on October 07, 2017, 01:27 PM, Quote from: bobfog on October 07, 2017, 01:34 PM, Quote from: Timtool on October 08, 2017, 04:19 AM, Quote from: Michael Kellough on October 08, 2017, 12:42 PM, Quote from: Svar on October 08, 2017, 12:44 PM, Quote from: ben_r_ on October 20, 2017, 01:03 PM, Quote from: Svar on October 20, 2017, 01:43 PM, Quote from: Michael Kellough on October 20, 2017, 03:30 PM, Quote from: antss on October 21, 2017, 09:09 AM. Crikey, get over it! I do like the X-Carve but I went with Shapeoko in the end. This looks intriguing. I cant believe that people would claim a CNC bed is better! . Jeremy Blumthrew together a simple touchscreen control panel that logs spindle metrics in real-time, and allows them to push the spindles until they break. All in all, i like what i see, and i think i would have done things in a similar way if i had to (i mean the conception process, not the actual product). The lessons from the previous were all combined into one. This one tool remains compact (as of now, i have bins of tools), AND i can use my skills in CAD design rather than my bad wood working skills. We're committed to making precision cutting easy and accessible to everyone and your support, not to mention incredible work, keeps us focused on expanding and improving the Shaper System. Same tool, same design. They were pretty reliable at running themselves. My father always told me to buy a decent tool, spend a little more money and you can use it the rest of your life. From reading most of what is above it seems were not allowed to actually like anything. The lift handle is now integrated flush with the tower, and the entire assembly is housed in an aluminum unibody construction. Thankfully they gave us a great set of highlights. Your use cases are a bit of a stretch, with the exception of working offsite where Ill grant that the Origin could have a big advantage. The tag on the side of the bit packaging contains the essential data: UC . There is no dust collection mechanism included in the box (dust boot), which is a bit of a let-down, as its so vital to using a CNC machine safely. Interesting; while I dont use a hand-held router every day, its one of my preferred tools for heaps things when a near-perfect edge is needed. Also have licenses for V-Carve (Handibot), MeshCAM, Fusion & Carbide Create. Since all it requires is the fiducial tape, it can make anything from the size of a matchbox to something as big as a thirty foot conference table. Unlike most AR devices, it doesnt just augment the data available to you, it actually changes physical things about the world around it. We are growing a community of people who are interested in whittling and woodwork-related crafts. With a router you can set the cutting tool feed rate precisely, rails and motors guide the tool, here your hand movement sets the feed rate, and a low resolution positioning system guides the cutting tool. She has special interests in open source 3D printing for R&D and has spent a lot of time at different projects across the globe to learn more about 3D printing. We havent been able to hit it yet. No worries Leo. Each CAD/CAM package has it's own learning curve. I tend to agree with Daniel. Before you begin cutting, travel over your entire design in Aircut Mode to verify that your tape metre will be healthy throughout the cut. Wed love to see their data for all the routers in the market. And it must go back years at this point, and its still not released? They still offer pre-orders for $ 1499 from which you can deduct the $ 100 using the referral link here. Looks really good, much more innovative and forward thinking than the Shaper. Shaper Pro is a professional model designed for Origin users who want additional support with Origin. Due to the material memory, sounds like you cant even have a set of over run boards, to allow you to get close to edges, because the second time you use them it will think youre cutting thin air. Origin users will appreciate spending their time fabricating iterating and experimenting. These include: You can see a preview of your work at any time, too. | Matter Hackers, The Main Differences Between X Carve vs Shapeoko, X-Carve Fully Loaded Kit comes in at around $1,999, Carbide 3D Shapeoko Standard | Matter Hackers, Check out MatterHackers for the latest prices here, 3D Printing for Jewelry: How It Works? Gone are the clunky handles and better industrial design begins to have its influence. https://preorder.shapertools.com/ref/21JHXJAM7. | Matter Hackers For most of the things Ive used a CNCor laser cutter for, this will do. Shapeoko uses Carbide Create, which is very simple to download and install. Why handhold/babysit when you can let the machine do its thing. The machine is portable, meaning you can build wherever you want and even drag it to job sites where it can cut out pieces. So with that tool, even at 2K euros, i could replace at least 600 worth of other tools (id obviously keep them, but appart from the drill to drill in walls, i dont see why not use this instead). This is especially important when its compensating for the unrestrained and uncoordinated movements of a Hackaday writer. The great thing about the Shapeoko is that the cheapest option the Shapeoko 3 is compact, meaning you can fit it into a smaller workshop, and it has a great price point of $1,170. It's amazing how little I appreciated learning these skills when I was younger. Home; Professional Development; About Us; Contact us Keeps them out, keeps me happy.) Continuing improvements are installed on the device. Well give the edge here to the X-Carve, as the cable tidy area works well, and the X-Controller is a great feature. Comparing this to a router is just ridiculous. Play slideshow. It comes in three sizes. In the end, were all hackers here, and most of us are far from dumb, so even if the product were to end up being bad, or unreliable, thats up to each to think before buying a pricey tool , read actual reviews, articles, and decide weather or not you have enough confidence in the tool to be good enough. It will be pushing me into construction methods that are more appropriate utilizing machinery over hand tools. Lets say you have a bit of baltic birchsitting in the corner of your shop. While moving along the path, the CNC controlled spindle makes minor movements to correct our imperfect human attempts to keep to the line. It goes without saying that a router cannot cut box joints on a horizontal sheet, as the bit is round and cannot cut proper corners: "is it worth it?" This can be improved using their belt sleeve, but its not completely alleviated, with some users having issues with it. I'd be way more concerned what happens if the company goes belly-up. Shapeoko is simple for people already exposed to far more complex tools, like machining centers, knee Mills, etc. I cant imagine trying to do complex operations that take hours with a hand operated machine. 1,782. The augmented portion is a suite of sensors and an onboard computer. looks like a mix of shaper and the maslow, of the three this one looks like the better executed. Every time I see this tool, it gets better. As of 10/17 I am out of the Dog business and pursuing other distractions. The main differences between X-Carve vs Shapeoko are: X-Carve can be customized if you're an experienced and avid CNC user with a variety of add-ons, whereas the Shapeoko comes as one unit with no add-ons X-Carve comes with a dust collector, whereas Shapeoko is a lot cheaper Cut a guide on the X-carve, use the guide on the wall with a flush-trim bit? The limitation to 3D work would be the size of the baseplate. I could see the company licensing their domino pattern to a drywall manufacturer, and making a smaller version of the router like a RotoZip. Your comment is similar to someone saying why buy a large router when a small mill is more accurate. If youre looking for investments, I have some land in Florida. Wed sum it up this way our: Most Budget Friendly:Shapeoko is most suitable for those on a tight budget, who want to give CNC-machining a go without spending nearly $2,000 on a machine. Only Hackaday has any content that is interesting about a new tool that is interesting to most of us. However, some reviewers say the instructions arent completely clear, which is a shame. No efforts need to be made to keep the tape in any particular alignment. For most of the things Ive wanted a full wood shop for, this will do. Hopefully this router is a small one with tiny bits. They have released a workstation for it and here is a video of it cutting some dovetails, looks a bit of a faff but I find it hard to get my . X-Carve can be customized if youre an experienced and avid CNC user with a variety of add-ons, whereas the Shapeoko comes as one unit with no add-ons, X-Carve comes with a dust collector, whereas Shapeoko is a lot cheaper, X-Carve is a cloud-based software, whereas Shapeoko is a software that can be installed onto your PC or Mac, X-Carve software has some features locked behind a paid plan, whereas Shapekos free software contains all the features upfront, X-Carve takes a long time to install, whereas Shapeoko comes part-installed, Customizable great if youre an experienced user, Software is pretty straightforward to learn (approachable learning curve), 2017 update has fixed a lot of issues that users had previously, The machine works well and at a good speed, The online community of users is a nice bonus, It can take a lot of adjusting to get to maximum accuracy, The software is great and has everything you need for free, Performance is good with especially smooth results when using wood, Takes some adjusting to get the accuracy just right. I see so many uses for this tool Guide to Stock Bits - Shaper An Arduino drives a floating head with some sandpaper glued to it back and forth. Mallet and glue to assemble. Its a fairly lengthy procedure depending on how experienced you are when it comes to installing machines like this, and you need to allow time for calibrating the CNC milling machine. Not as intrigued as many but I have changed from from an early implementor or purchaser. Thats my opinion, you may dont like it, so be it. Heres my pre-order code if you want to save $100 and help me defray the cost of getting clever ideas into the hands of people who make more clever ideas. :P. Ill bet they will eventually support Metric if/when this becomes a common product. Remember all the hype about the Glowforge 3D Laser Printer, another gimmicky product thats in perpetual preorder status? In addition, new updated and diffuse lighting provides better scanning performance across a range of different lighting conditions. The content contained on this site is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional advice. We didnt get the response, for the remaining 95% humans of this world, its an important one. The very first version of the Origin was a MIT research project. Sod woodworking, what about using it for fibreglass complex cutouts on boats, kitcars etc, or thin metal instant front panels and the like. Thread starter Bill Satko; Start date Dec 29, 2021; Bill Satko Member. Thats right Gen2 will be assembled in Weilheim, Germany, at Festools newest and most advanced production facility. Id imagine its also capable of etching (depending on Z-axis resolution), so thats another thing it can do. Goliath to slay Shaper Origin - Festoolownersgroup.com However, this can be easily fixed by buying a DeWalt dust collector.